Episode 246: The Utilization Debate: Should You Move Vehicles Between Drivers?

EPISODE 246FLEET UTILIZATION

The Utilization Debate: Should You Move Vehicles Between Drivers?

Five RTA fleet pros debate whether to reassign vehicles to balance utilization, and how switching friction, specialized upfits, and lifecycle math change the answer.

Hosted by Marc Canton

#1 PODCAST FOR FLEET PROS

Listen on your favorite app.

About This Episode

Should fleet managers reassign vehicles to balance utilization, or leave assets with their current operators and manage the differences through lifecycle planning?

It sounds like a simple fleet utilization question. It isn’t.

In this episode of The Fleet Success Show, five RTA fleet professionals debate one of the more nuanced questions in fleet asset management: When vehicles within the same asset class have dramatically different utilization rates, should fleet leaders move those assets between operators to keep mileage and usage closer to plan? The answer can have significant implications for vehicle replacement planning, residual value, total cost of ownership, warranty coverage, fleet availability, and long-term capital planning.

Marc Canton is joined by Sara Burnam, Scott Conlon, Drew Morrow, and Jake Johnson to examine the issue from public-sector, consulting, heavy-duty, emergency-management, and fleet-operations perspectives. The group explores why low-utilization vehicles can be just as important to identify as high-utilization assets; when reassigning vehicles can protect lifecycle economics; and why simply having two identical vehicles does not necessarily mean they belong in the same lifecycle or utilization class.

They also examine the human side of utilization management. Drivers and departments can develop a sense of ownership over assigned vehicles, creating what the group calls “switching friction.” That means the mathematically optimal fleet decision may not always be the most practical one. Fleet leaders have to consider the time, political capital, operational disruption, and organizational culture required to make a change.

The discussion gets especially interesting with specialized assets. Is it financially responsible to move a former patrol vehicle into an administrative role? When does the cost of removing specialized upfits outweigh the savings? Could cycling a heavy-duty truck from high-mileage highway service into lower-mileage city service extend its useful life? And should fleets deliberately maximize vehicle use while an asset is under warranty?

The central takeaway is not that every fleet should constantly rotate vehicles. It’s that fleet utilization should be actively managed with data rather than allowed to become a blind spot. Sometimes that means reassigning an asset. Sometimes it means creating a different utilization class or replacement cycle. And sometimes the operational friction means another strategy makes more sense. The important thing is being able to defend the decision with data.

Key Takeaways

Not every fleet should constantly rotate vehicles. Utilization should be actively managed with data, so every reassignment decision can be defended.

When vehicle reassignment can improve fleet utilization

How utilization affects replacement timing and total cost of ownership

Why high-mileage assets can negatively affect residual value

How to identify and manage high- and low-utilization outliers

When identical vehicles may require different lifecycle strategies

Why organizational culture and “switching friction” affect reassignment

When specialized vehicles should, or shouldn't, be repurposed

How warranty periods can influence utilization strategy

Why replacement scoring can help prioritize assets within the same class

How better utilization data supports defensible capital decisions

Meet the Speakers

Marc Canton

HOST

Marc Canton

VP of Fleet Strategy, RTA

Marc Canton is VP of Fleet Strategy at RTA Fleet and a longtime fleet industry leader focused on helping organizations build safer, more reliable, and more efficient operations. Drawing on extensive experience across fleet management and consulting, Marc brings a practical, operator-first perspective to improving performance, managing costs, and using data and technology to make better fleet decisions.

VIEW PROFILE ›
Sara Burnam

GUEST

Sara Burnam

Fleet Success Manager, RTA

Sara is a Fleet Success Manager at RTA with approximately 27 years of fleet industry experience. Her perspective on utilization management is informed by firsthand experience identifying underutilized vehicles, repurposing assets, and avoiding unnecessary replacements.

Scott Conlon

GUEST

Scott Conlon

Fleet Management Consultant, RTA

Scott Conlon works on RTA's fleet consulting team and brings approximately 25 years of fleet industry experience. He challenges fleets to consider not only the economics of vehicle utilization but also lifecycle classifications, replacement scoring, organizational culture, and the effort required to move assets between users.

GUEST

Drew Morrow

Fleet Success Manager, RTA

Drew Morrow is a Fleet Success Manager at RTA with 15 years of experience leading fleets. Drawing on his background in fleet operations and emergency management, Drew examines vehicle reassignment through the lenses of asset use case, operational requirements, remarketing, and the data fleet leaders need to justify utilization decisions.

Jake Johnson

GUEST

Jake Johnson

Fleet Success Manager, RTA

Jake Johnson is a Fleet Success Manager at RTA with more than 20 years of experience on the heavy-duty commercial side of the fleet industry. His perspective highlights how utilization strategies can differ by asset type, including heavy-duty vehicles that move from high-mileage applications to lower-mileage duty cycles later in their lives.

PODCAST HOT TAKES

Short on Time? Start Here.

Four quick clips from this episode, each under a minute.

Car Batteries Can Grow Mold?!?

Low Mileage Doesn't Always Mean Higher Vehicle Value

Would You Give This Police Vehicle to a Civilian Driver?

That Unused Fleet Vehicle Could Cost You $1,000/Month

The Fleet Success Playbook book

The Fleet Success Playbook

Written by fleet professionals for fleet professionals: the four pillars of fleet success and the tools to build a great fleet. Free.

Get Your Free Copy ›

Control fleet chaos with RTA Fleet360, proven software designed by fleet managers for fleet managers. Book a Demo today.