5 Costly Fleet Software Implementation Mistakes (& How to Avoid Them)

"If you're leaving an old system because the reporting was trash, odds are it wasn't the reporting—it was your data." – Josh Turley

Implementing a fleet management information system (FMIS) should be a game-changer for your fleet operations. Done right, it can reduce costs, improve efficiency, and give you better insights into your fleet’s performance. Done wrong? It can lead to months of delays, frustration, and wasted investment.

So, why do so many fleet software implementations fail? At RTA, we’ve seen thousands of implementations—some wildly successful, others absolute disasters. In this guide, we’ll break down the most common pitfalls and how to avoid them, so your fleet software rollout is a success from day one.

This article is based on a recent episode of The Fleet Success Show podcast. Watch the full episode below:

1. Data Migration Nightmares

"The first thing out of the gate, when I see an implementation going off the rails, almost always, it involves some type of data migration issue." – Josh Turley

One of the biggest pitfalls in any FMIS implementation is data migration. If your old system’s data is messy, outdated, or inconsistent, transferring it into a new system without cleanup will only make things worse.

Common Data Migration Mistakes:

🚨 Not having access to your old FMIS – If your old system is locked down, migrating data becomes a nightmare. Secure access early.
🚨 Bringing over bad data – If your previous system was filled with errors, duplicates, or outdated records, don’t migrate it blindly.
🚨 Underestimating time needed for data validation – If you don’t allocate time to clean and validate data, your reports will still be garbage.

How to Avoid Data Issues:

✅ Audit your existing data before migration. Remove duplicates and standardize formats.
✅ Decide what’s worth keeping—do you really need 10 years of old transactional data? Probably not.
✅ Work with a provider that understands fleet data. At RTA, we offer data migration services to ensure you only transfer what’s valuable.

💡 Want to see how RTA simplifies data migration? Schedule a demo today!

2. Underestimating Time & Resources

"Fleet managers think they can just plug in a new system and it will magically work—but that’s not how it happens." – Marc Canton

Many fleets underestimate how much time a successful implementation takes. Software rollouts involve:

• System setup & configuration
• Data migration & validation
• User training
• Testing & troubleshooting

If you don’t budget the time to properly transition, your implementation will stall.

How to Stay on Track:

✅ Set realistic timelines – If you need full historical data migration, expect 90+ days, not 30.
✅ Dedicate internal resources – Who will oversee implementation on your team? If no one owns the process, it will fail.
✅ Work with a provider that streamlines onboarding. RTA offers 30-day implementations for fleets bringing in only core data.

📅 Ready to roll out your FMIS the right way? Book a free implementation consultation!

3. Ignoring Process Improvement Opportunities

"There's a reason why you're leaving your old provider. Don't just copy bad processes into a new system." – Marc Canton

A fleet software upgrade is the perfect time to fix outdated workflows. Yet, many fleets simply replicate their old processes in the new system—problems and all.

Avoid This Mistake:

🚫 Don't say, "That's just how we do it." Be open to process improvements.
🚫 Don't over-customize the new system to match old inefficiencies.
🚫 Don't miss the chance to improve reporting & analytics by setting up data correctly from day one.

✅ Solution: Work with your FMIS provider to optimize your workflows instead of just copying old ones. At RTA, we consult with fleets to engineer better processes, not just migrate bad habits.

4. Integration Failures

"We’ve seen fleets get six months into implementation only to find out a critical integration won’t be available for years." – Josh Turley

If your FMIS needs to integrate with fuel systems, GPS tracking, accounting software, or other tools, verify compatibility before signing a contract.

How to Avoid Integration Pitfalls:

✅ Confirm integrations before purchase – Don’t assume your software can “just connect.”
✅ Get all stakeholders involved early – IT, accounting, and fleet teams should be part of vendor discussions.
✅ Choose an FMIS with flexible API support – RTA Fleet360 integrates with major fleet tools to keep your operations connected.

🚀 Want an FMIS that actually works with your existing tools? Schedule a demo today.

5. Skipping Training (The #1 Mistake)

"The #1 reason fleets hate their software? They don’t know how to use it." – Mark Canton

Even the best fleet software won’t help if your team doesn’t know how to use it. Many implementations fail because fleets skip training, leaving staff frustrated and underprepared.

How to Ensure Training Success:

✅ Make training part of your implementation plan – Don't treat it as an afterthought.
✅ Invest in ongoing education – As team members come and go, training should be continuous.
✅ Hold users accountable – Ensure staff actually complete training before using the system.

💡 RTA includes ongoing training with every implementation. Find out more!

Make Your Fleet Software Implementation a Success

A successful FMIS rollout isn’t just about the software—it’s about clean data, clear processes, proper integration, and a fully trained team.

At RTA, we take implementation seriously—helping fleets avoid common pitfalls and get up and running faster.

👉 See how RTA Fleet360 makes implementation easy. Schedule a free demo today!